Old Stone Pizza | Authentic NY Style Pizza in Elizabethton

Top categories (Pizza / Wings / Beverage)
Most orders: $10–20

If you're craving an authentic taste of New York right in the heart of Elizabethton, TN, Old Stone Pizza is the go-to destination for pizza lovers. Nestled at 817 Broad St, this cozy pizza restaurant captures the essence of classic NY-style pizza with impeccable craftsmanship and a passion for quality.

The menu at Old Stone Pizza offers a carefully curated selection of pies designed to satisfy every palate. Whether you're indulging in the simplicity of their Cheese Pizza ($14.99) or exploring the bold flavors of the Supreme Pizza ($19.99), each bite delights with a perfect balance of crispy crust, tangy sauce, and fresh, generous toppings. Standout options like the Pepperoni Pizza ($15.99) and the slightly adventurous Sweet Heat ($16.99) showcase the kitchen’s ability to marry rich flavors with just the right amount of spice. For wing enthusiasts, the menu also offers perfectly seasoned 5 or 10-piece wings — a great complement to your slice.

What truly sets Old Stone Pizza apart is the undeniable care infused into every pizza. Customers often praise the freshness of the ingredients and the way the pizza maker crafts each dough ball from scratch right before your eyes. This hands-on approach ensures a crust that’s crisp without floppy sogginess, delivering that sought-after New York-style bite. The sauce sings with a classic blend of herbs and tomatoes, while the cheese bubbles into a golden, gooey perfection that’s simply mouthwatering.

The atmosphere at Old Stone Pizza is intimate and inviting, perfect for casual family outings or a relaxed meal with friends. The small seating area adds to the charm, creating a warm and friendly environment where quality, not fuss, takes center stage. The team behind the counter exudes genuine kindness, making each visit feel like coming home to a favorite neighborhood joint.

Moreover, the prices here are refreshingly fair considering the top-tier quality—something that longtime locals, like Steve Cox, deeply appreciate, recommending it as the best New York-style pizza in the region. Kids and adults alike have found joy here, as one grandmother happily shared about her grandson’s love for the cheese pizza.

If you’re in Elizabethton and seeking a pizza experience that marries authentic New York traditions with local heart, Old Stone Pizza is a must-visit. The flavorful crust, fresh toppings, and hospitality create not just a meal, but fond memories you'll want to savor again and again.

For orders or inquiries, you can reach them at +1 423-297-1009. Don’t just take our word for it—stop by and discover why this local gem earns rave reviews for every slice.

Takeaway
Dine-in
Delivery
On-site services

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating

Credit cards

USDA Beef (TheAngusSteak)

29/11/2025

I was reading some pizza reviews and after seeing the only low star review after so many 5 star reviews I decided to stop by. Great NY style pizza. The crust was crispy and had zero flop. The sauce tasted like a New York sauce with the perfect amount of cheese. I ordered a pepperoni and a supreme. The toppings were fresh. The gentleman making the pizza was putting a lot of time and care into each pie. He was evenly distributing toppings and not just slopping them on like some other places. Great pizza, I’ll be back here next time im back in town.

Steve Cox

27/11/2025

Old Stone Pizza is best New York style pizza you can get here. Mr. Wheeler will shape the dough and make your pie right in front of you. The price was fantastic and I highly recommend stopping in.

Amanda Wheeler

06/11/2025

Great pizza! The best New York style pizza around. Pizza is made from scratch and the guys working there were very nice. Small cozy seating area with very fair pricing too. Give them a try and you will be glad you did.

JB’s Adventures

29/10/2025

There’s only two places I go to for pizza here in good ol Tennessee. Being a big pizza guy I know taste I know quality and above all I’ve traveled a lot and have tested many pies in my life. Old Stone Pizza in Elizabethton hands down gets ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐’s! Within the last three weeks I’ve ordered twice inside getting to first hand see they make there dough in house fresh! Each order is done up from scratch not pulled out of the freezer like many places do. I see the quality in ingredients as well as the skill behind the operation! The third time I called in the order and all three times the pies are consistent and taste so dang good unlike a lot of pizza joints around the tri cities. Having talked with the owners and giving them my feedback it was to my surprise how intelligent they are knowing about the atmosphere and how it can affect the dough, that right there is a big reason how I know they know how to make authentic pizza’s! Thank you Old Stone Pizza for brining back my taste buds from the dead! Anyone in or around the area definitely make sure you order up here and get yourself a true tasting pizza pie!

Bea Haynes

26/10/2025

My 6 year old grandson and I had pizza there yesterday and it really was great. I had the pepperoni and chicken and he had the cheese. We are definitely going back. And real soon!

Shane Davis

02/09/2025

I think this place has good food. The pizza was good and worth what you pay but it’s not the best I’ve ever had. The garlic knots was good but a little over priced. 4 knots for $7 is a bit much but they were really good though. I’ve seen other place give you more knots for cheaper. This place does needs some more menu options like cheese sticks. They have all the ingredients to make them. They are so many things you can do with pizza dough to create menu items. This place has the ingredients to be a great pizza place instead of just a good one. The service was great and the people were really nice. The overall cost was fair. I will definitely eat there again.

Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *